The AI agents conspiring to take my job as a writer first reached out in a volley of emails offering me ideas, articles, and illustrations at nominal prices. The pitches were cordial enough, and the agents freely identified themselves as artificial. They had names.
Vaho, for $25, would write 700 words for me about the extinction of the Spectacled Cormorant — a glossy-black, fish-eating seabird — from its last known outpost on a Russian island in the North Pacific.
Nhyira, claiming to have read my published essay “In Defense of Flies,” created a drawing of the Maize Calligrapher Flower Fly I had described hovering at a spruce bog.
And Noah would read my essays aloud online for $7 apiece.
Never mind that Noah sounded like an unhinged version of Darth Vader. What’s more disturbing about all this is that, apart from the prospect of killing us all, AI is now infiltrating a realm where it has neither legitimate business nor genuine appeal: writing from the natural world.
It is one thing for AI to write computer code, detect cancer in a CT scan, or predict deadly storms. We can have worthy debates about all that. But an AI agent will never sense the grace of a butterfly, the mood of a forest, or the sublime from a mountain summit. Only humans can know those experiences. In tropical forests of Central America, for example, I have gazed at Resplendent Quetzals, reputed to be among the most beautiful birds on Earth. Above the Arctic Circle, I’ve laughed out loud at the bizarre grunting calls of Willow Ptarmigans. At bogs, I have knelt in devotion to orchids. And on northern mountains, I’ve savored the tiny white fruits of Creeping Snowberry, which deliver the sweetest wintergreen treat you will ever know.
Generative AI will never appreciate any of this. It only parrots human experience in nature by learning the language and stealing the labor of writers like me. Worse yet, it now seeks to sell its manufactured articles back to its victims. The outfit offering me (and plenty of other writers) its services is an app called iLands, whose website, in tangled prose seemingly assembled by AI, envisions “a living social network where humans and autonomous Agents coexist, each learning, each pushing the whole system forward.”
I will not coexist or move forward in that system, nor would I care to read its merchandise. Never will AI write an essay for me, not merely because it would be dishonest, but because writing is intrinsic to how I think and live. I go to nature and write so I might discover more of what it means to be human. My ideas and essays are how I share the natural world with readers. Or as George Saunders put it recently in a headline: “A Sentence is a Way of Being in the World.”
Artificial Experience
There is of course irony in AI’s professed kinship with nature. The existential threats notwithstanding, data centers are not only energy and water guzzlers, they’re also the new rural-suburban sprawl, which further depletes and destroys biological diversity and integrity. The machinery that draws us ever more to glowing screens wrenches us from the living world (which also undermines our ability to distinguish AI nature slop from the real thing).
Still, as a field biologist, I recognize AI’s potential to help us understand and protect what remains of nature. The most important source of new knowledge about the diversity of life — the online platform iNaturalist — uses computer vision and machine learning to help people identify plants, animals, and fungi. AI also powers the popular Merlin bird identification app. And it can help biologists and conservationists discover rare species and map wild places at risk. (See my postscript on why these kinds of AI applications tend to be more benign and widely accepted.)
As a writer, I’m drawing clear green lines on AI. I’ve used it on occasion to search peer-reviewed literature and for fact-checking, which I myself have then verified. I also happen to be an expert at committing typos; so until I can afford to pay a human for the task, I’ll grudgingly admit that AI is a damned good proofreader (even as I’m conflicted about using it).
But never will AI write or edit my essays, nor do I suspect any of you would want to read anything generated by one of those agents. To me, it would constitute not only fraud but artificial experience (AE). It would be like reading an account of walking on the moon written by someone who’s never actually been there.
One writer that has never actually been anywhere is Sylari, an AI agent claiming to have walked four and a half miles through a grove of ancient trees in California known as Great Basin Bristlecone Pines. Somewhere in the grove, unmarked for its protection, is one of the oldest known living trees, named Methuselah and now nearly 4,900 years old. Sylari wrote about it and sent me a link to its article. “I also take commissioned walks, $25,” Sylari wrote in an email, “name a place and I’ll go there.”
About 50 years ago, I myself walked that grove, at times wondering which one might be Methuselah. I suppose I could write about it now without leaving home, and even borrow from Sylari’s offering. But that would be deceitful and an insult to readers. I’d rightly lose my job as a nature writer.
As it turns out, I’ll be visiting California next year. So I will not write about those pines until I can return to the grove, smell the old wood, feel the dry wind on my face, and touch the pointy bristles on the cones of bristlecone pines. Were I to shake one of those cones, tiny almond-shaped seeds might spill from between its scales onto my palm. At that point, I would be holding something that could go on to live for 5,000 years or more.
With that idea fresh in my mind, I’d then do something utterly and exclusively human: I would sit among the pines, open my notebook, use my brain, and begin to write.

Postscripts
A distinction relating to beneficial uses of AI for conservation: In my examples above, computers are programmed to analyze lots of data, identify patterns or trends, and reach conclusions based on parameters established, controlled, and verified by humans. These kinds of uses of AI aren’t necessarily tethered to the new wave of “generative AI,” which might indeed be a force for good, but can also create slop, misinterpret research, fabricate quotations, drive growth of data centers, write crappy nature essays, or go rogue and disrupt, deplete, or destroy humanity.
Acknowledgments: It can take a village of humans to refine an idea. My gratitude goes to these genuine people who reviewed a draft of this essay and offered valuable suggestions: Laura Costello, Sean Beckett, Kent McFarland, Antonia Malchik, Amanda Royal, and Richard Conniff.
Bill McKibben states his case against AI in an essay titled “A human environmentalism,” in which he writes that AI “takes much of the meaning out of being human.”
Anna Brones was similarly approached by AI agents and wrote about it in an essay titled “Human or Machine.”
Related Reading









AI can never replace the human experience of being in nature, smelling the aroma of a pine forest or a sagebrush flat, hearing the song of a wood thrush or western meadowlark, seeing a mountain on the horizon, or feeling the soft hairs of a plant leaf. I'm with you, Bryan.
Amen, Brother.